Hablamos Espanol
Hablamos Espanol
The intoxication defense allows a carrier to deny a Florida workers’ compensation claim on the basis that the injury was caused by drugs or alcohol. Under Florida Statute § 440.09(3), compensation is not payable if the injury was occasioned primarily by the employee’s intoxication, or by the influence of drugs not prescribed by a physician.
Note the word. The statute does not deny benefits because a worker had a substance in their system. It denies them where intoxication or drug influence was the primary occasion of the injury.
The same subsection also excludes injury occasioned primarily by the willful intention of the employee to injure or kill themselves or another.
Where the employer has reason to suspect the injury was occasioned primarily by intoxication or by drug use affecting the employee to the extent that normal faculties were impaired — and the employer has not implemented a drug-free workplace under §§ 440.101 and 440.102 — the employer may require the employee to submit to a test for drugs or alcohol.
Testing may not commence until the agency has adopted rules for the authorization and regulation of drug testing policies, procedures and methods. Where results are positive, the testing facility must maintain the specimen for a minimum of 90 days.
This is the heart of the defense. If at the time of injury the employee has a blood alcohol level at or above the level specified in § 316.193, or a positive confirmation of a drug as defined in the act, it is presumed the injury was occasioned primarily by the intoxication or drug influence.
How you rebut it depends on the employer:
Rebuttal also carries a specific evidentiary requirement: the injured worker must prove the actual quantitative amounts of the drug or its metabolites as measured on the initial and confirmation post-accident tests, and must provide evidence of the absence of drug influence beyond simply denying it.
Employer acquiescence. If, before the accident, the employer had actual knowledge of and expressly acquiesced in the employee’s presence at the workplace while under the influence, the presumptions do not apply at all.
Blood serum testing. Where a blood serum test is used, the presumptions do not arise unless the blood alcohol level is proved to be medically and scientifically equivalent to or greater than the comparable level that would have been obtained by a percent-by-weight blood test.
Refusal carries its own presumption. If the injured worker refuses to submit to a drug test, it is presumed — in the absence of clear and convincing evidence to the contrary — that the injury was occasioned primarily by the influence of drugs.
A positive post-accident test is a serious problem but not necessarily a fatal one. Whether the presumption applies at all, and what is required to rebut it, depends on the employer’s drug-free workplace status, the testing method, the quantitative results, and what the employer knew beforehand.
Those are all factual questions, and they need to be examined before the claim is written off.
A positive confirmation creates a presumption that the injury was occasioned primarily by drug influence, which can defeat the claim. The presumption is rebuttable, though the standard depends on whether your employer implemented a drug-free workplace program.
Rebutting the presumption requires proving the actual quantitative amounts on the initial and confirmation tests plus evidence of absence of drug influence beyond your own denial. Detection alone is not the same as impairment, but the burden sits with the worker.
Refusing creates a presumption, absent clear and convincing evidence to the contrary, that the injury was occasioned primarily by the influence of drugs. Refusal generally makes the position worse.
If the employer had actual knowledge before the accident and expressly acquiesced in your presence at the workplace while under the influence, the statutory presumptions do not apply.
Reviewed by: Scott J. Sternberg