Hablamos Espanol

Call Today for Free Consultation

phone call

Earning Capacity

Home » Glossary » Earning Capacity

Last Reviewed: October 30, 2026

Reviewed by Scott J. Sternberg

Earning capacity is what an injured worker is able to earn after an injury, as distinct from what they actually earn. Florida’s definition of disability turns on it: § 440.02 defines disability as incapacity because of the injury to earn, in the same or any other employment, the wages the employee was receiving at the time of the injury.

Disability means lost earning ability

Note what that definition does not say. Disability is not defined by pain, by diagnosis, or by impairment. It is defined by the effect on your ability to earn.

A worker with a serious injury who returns to full wages has, in this statutory sense, no disability — even while genuinely impaired. That is why impairment benefits exist separately: they compensate permanent loss of function regardless of earnings.

Where earning capacity is decided

  • Temporary partial disability. TPD compares your pre-injury average weekly wage against what you are able to earn post-injury. The statute provides the amount deemed earnable is in no case less than what you are actually earning, including sheltered employment.
  • Permanent total disability. The test is whether you can perform at least sedentary employment within 50 miles of your residence.
  • Vocational rehabilitation. Retraining turns on inability to earn at least 80% of the compensation rate at MMI.
  • Return from PTD. Where a worker receiving permanent total disability becomes rehabilitated to the extent of establishing an earning capacity, they move to impairment benefits instead.

Deemed earnings

The concept that catches people out. Earning capacity can be attributed to you whether or not you are actually earning it.

Where an employee receiving temporary partial disability leaves the employment without just cause, benefits are payable based on deemed earnings — calculated as if the employee had remained employed. The practical effect is that quitting a light-duty job can leave you paid on wages you are no longer receiving.

Similar reasoning drives labor market surveys in permanent total disability cases: the carrier seeks to establish that work exists which you are capable of performing, whether or not you hold it.

The trial return to work

A protection worth knowing. Section 440.15(1)(d) directs the department to adopt rules enabling a permanently and totally disabled employee who may have re-established an earning capacity to undertake a trial period of reemployment without prejudicing their return to permanent total status if they cannot sustain it.

Attempting work should not automatically cost you the benefit if the attempt fails.

Where earning capacity disputes go wrong

  • Capacity assumed from physical findings alone. Suitable gainful employment is a whole-person test.
  • Deemed earnings applied after a justified departure. Leaving with just cause is treated differently, and the reasons need documenting at the time.
  • Labor market surveys unchallenged. Their quality varies enormously.
  • Fear of attempting work. The trial reemployment provision exists precisely so an attempt is not automatically penalised.
  • Earnings not reported. Failing to notify the carrier within five business days of returning to work suspends TPD.

What this means for your claim

Because disability is measured by lost earning ability, what you are able to earn is contested more often than what you are able to lift.

If you are leaving a post-injury job, document why, before you go — the difference between just cause and no just cause determines whether you are paid on real wages or deemed ones. And if you want to try work you are not sure you can sustain, ask about trial reemployment first.

Frequently asked questions

What you are able to earn after your injury, as opposed to what you actually earn. Florida defines disability as incapacity because of the injury to earn the wages you were receiving at the time of injury, so earning capacity drives most benefit determinations.

Earnings attributed to you that you are not actually receiving. Where a worker on temporary partial disability leaves employment without just cause, benefits are calculated as though they had remained employed.

Section 440.15(1)(d) directs rules allowing a permanently and totally disabled employee who may have re-established an earning capacity to undertake a trial period of reemployment without prejudicing a return to permanent total status if it cannot be sustained.

Not in the statutory sense, because disability is defined by lost earning ability. Impairment income benefits compensate permanent loss of function separately, regardless of earnings.